In many countries, the population consists of many nationalities; some are more diverse than others. Cultural and Ethnic considerations should be taken into account and respected. To my knowledge, Cultural Considerations has not really had a thread devoted to this topic, yet it is an issue that may have an impact on the course of a pandemic.
Culture is loosely defined as the totality of socially transmitted behavioral patterns, expression of arts, beliefs (voiced or not), values, customs, and thought characteristics of a population of people that guide their view of the world and decision-making in their lives. These patterns may be explicit or implicit, are primarily learned and transmitted within the family, are shared by most members of the culture, and are emergent phenomena that may change in response to global phenomena. Culture is largely unconscious and has powerful influences on health and illness.
Consider the health practices of people of different heritage… or their death and burial practices. Look at what we have learned just by translating news in the Indonesian Thread. They seek cures from the village healer. They do not always seek help from a hospital or physician. Some would rather take medicinal herbs before they would take “western medicine”. For their deceased loved ones, they wash the bodies, and bury as soon as possible. There is much touching of the dead, but they (for the most part) do not allow autopsies.
Some cultural aspects of individuals or groups are actually religious in nature. Many cultural aspects are traditions that have been passed down from generation to generation.
Cultural diversity is dependant on many things and tends to be individualized when you get down to the specifics. Factors that may contribute to this would be how and where they were raised, where they reside now, the length of time the person has been outside the influence of their native culture, the age of the person, their exposure to other cultures, etc.
Even though the individual(s) should be respected for their beliefs, sometimes it is difficult to understand the why’s and what’s of someone else’s culture when it may be vastly different from our own. Understanding a culture may also allow some insight into how we can integrate individual’s beliefs into any interventions that may be needed to mitigate the impact of a pandemic.
Your insight into the following cultural norms may prove to be beneficial in implementing those interventions.
This model is used in health care, yet it has a truth inherent for all of us who interact with other people.
PURNELL MODEL
1. All cultures share core similarities.
2. One culture is not better than another culture; they are just different.
3. Cultures change slowly over time.
4. Differences exist within, between, and among cultures.
5. Culture has a powerful influence on one’s interpretation of and responses to health care.
6. To be effective, health care must reflect the unique understanding of the values, beliefs, attitudes, and worldview of diverse populations and individual acculturation patterns.
7. Learning culture is an ongoing process that develops in a variety of ways, primarily through cultural encounters.
8. Prejudices and biases can be minimized with cultural understanding.
9. Cultural awareness improves the caregiver’s self-awareness.
10. Each individual has the right to be respected for his or her uniqueness and cultural heritage.
11. Individuals and families belong to several cultural groups.
12. If clients are coparticipants in their care and have a choice in health-related goals, plans, and interventions, their compliance and health outcomes will be improved.
13. Differences in race and culture often require adaptations to standard interventions.
14. The primary and secondary characteristics of culture determine the extent to which one varies from his/her dominant culture.
15. Caregivers need both culture-general and culture-specific information in order to provide culturally sensitive and competent care.
16. Caregivers who can assess, plan, intervene, and evaluate in a culturally competent manner will improve their care of clients.
17. All health-care professions share the metaparadigm concepts of global society, family, person, and health.
18. All health-care professions need similar information about cultural diversity.
19. Professions, organizations, and associations have their own culture, which can be analyzed using a grand theory of culture.
Interesting! I’m waiting to read the rest of it.
Since the Amish were recently in the news…. I will start with them.
The Amish
OVERVIEW AND HERITAGE
Today’s Amish live in rural areas in more than 20 states. They have settled in states westward from Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana to as far west as Montana, with a few scattered settlements in Florida and the province of Ontario, Canada. But, more than half live in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana. The Old Order Amish, so-called for their strict observance of traditional ways that distinguish them from other, more progressive “plain folk,” are the largest and most notable group.
The Amish originated around 1693, when they parted ways with the Anabaptist movement that occured in Switzerland in 1525. After experiencing severe persecution and martyrdom in Europe, the Amish and related groups immigrated to North America in the 17th and 18th centuries. The Amish groups or settlements are sometimes named after their factional leaders (for example Egli and Beachy Amish); and some are called conservative Amish Mennonites; and other, New Order Amish. No Amish live in Europe today.
The Amish have transplanted and preserved a way of life that has the appearance of pre-industrial European peasantry. In the U. S., they have persisted in relative social isolation based on religious principles. Over time, the Amish have continued to adapt and change at their own pace, accepting innovations selectively. Although most Amish homes do not have electric and electronic labor-saving devices and appliances, that does not preclude their openness to using state-of-the-art medical technology necessary for health promotion.
COMMUNICATIONS
AMISH (continued)
FAMILY ROLES AND ORGANIZATION
BIOCULTURAL ECOLOGY
The Amish are essentially a closed population, with exogamy occurring very rarely. Most are of German and Swiss descent; therefore, their physical characteristics differ, with skin variations ranging from light to olive tones. Hair and eye colors vary accordingly.
NUTRITION
AMISH (Continued)
PREGNANCY AND CHILDBEARING PRACTICES
DEATH RITUALS
SPIRITUALITY
HEALTH-CARE PRACTICES
AMISH (Continued)
HEALTH-CARE PRACTITIONERS
PLEASE NOTE:
I should have added at the beginning, I will try to go thru the “list” alphabetically… If you think I have missed a culture that should be discussed, please let me know.
Also, While I did reference the internet and a book that I have, the observations listed may not reflect exactly your perception (or practice) of that culture. Please feel free to discuss what I’ve written and any differences you may find. This will help bring a better understanding to each culture.
My observations:
I believe the Amish will fare well if the power, and communications fail since they have cultivated a way of life that would be impacted in a minimal way.
They have food and the necessities of living as well as the knowledge necessary to maintain the “supply”.
They have the support of the community, so that even families that are ill may have care.
They have knowledge of folk remedies that may or may not have any effect on the course of influenza, although for symptom relief they probably will do better than most of us if there is a general lack of medication.
They also have no real aversion to modern medications and vaccines and / or hospitalizations if it is deemed necessary and is available.
One concern would be that someone, whom the Amish elders respect, should speak to them about the use of antivirals and vaccines. They could then be better able to set up distribution points for the delivery and administration to the community.
I live in a community with many Amish and Mennonites. Heres a few of my observations. They are not anti medicine. Patients Ive treated were hooked up to all the bells and whistles. They have remarkedly low instances of CAD and low LDL levels despite diets high in fats????? They are remarkedly complient with drs orders. They have a great respect for the medicial community.
They tend to distrust government, God is the final authority. So for instance I dont know if they would suspend church meetings during a pandemic. Each church is different its going to depend on the particular leadership in each church They are completely autonmous. Reaching them with news is going to require local officials personally contacting the leaders. They really dont know much about currant events. Life for them is in the church community they live in. The children attend private church schools. or are home schooled. Lastly they are pacifists, this may doom them during a pandemic
“effect” should be “affect” (sorry)
One thing to consider…. The Amish live mostly in the north. But wherever their communities are, they may be inudated with people looking to get out of the cities. This will have an unknown impact, as the Amish are generally believed to help other people in times of need.
The Amish rely on authorities for law enforcement. They do have their “rule-breakers”, but generally crime is pretty low. They may not have the means to “control” a number of people into their communities. Nor do most communities have the capibility to handel large crowds of people, except for communities who also function as a tourist destination. Even there, the Amish manage to keep their private lives private.
This aspect may prove to be an issue for them.
janetn – at 16:20
You wrote: Lastly they are pacifists, this may doom them during a pandemic.
Your word “pacifist” is the most apt use of the word for this group of people. Their belief in GOD, and their belief that GOD is in control of destiny, and has the power of vengence is one of the guiding princples of their lives. The Amish have a saying…. “Gottes Wille” (or “God’s Will.”).
Because of their beliefs, a severe pandemic which causes migration(s) of people from the cities in search of a safe haven, may very well cause a further disruption in the lives of these people.
I value my Mennonite, Quaker and Amish friends and neighbors.
They do have objection to the use of any force. “they that take up the sword shall perish by the sword. Vengeance is mine I shall repay, saith the Lord.” I draw the line at initiation of force only, and I take particular exception to thugs taking advantage of the gentler people around.
Florida Girl- My culture is that of the Highland Scots-Irish immigrant to the United States. I would be interested in your assessment of that particular culture, if you have one.
LM My thoughts exactly. My neighbors are Mennonite they are wonderful people.
Florida Girl 16:01
How soon will it be before you post something similar for the American Indian culture? Is there a link you have you could post that I could look at?
Thanks
They education of Amish/Mennonites re AF and the possibility of a pandemic is probably the first thing that officials should be doing. They are definatly not in the loop as of today. There coperation and assistance during a pandemic would be valuable. they are masters of helping their neighbor, including “the English”. Hmmm think Im going to have to have some coffee with my neighbor, see what access I can gain to educate them, Im sure they will be much less frustrating to deal with than my public officials.
Florida Girl --- Is there a way to shorten the descriptions of what your attempting to do here (or simply link to your sources)? That way, we don’t have a bazillion threads opened about various cultures.
Please don’t think that I’m looking down on this or have any problem with what you’re doing here. I’m only thinking about the number of threads that could possibly come to fruition… :-)
Bronco Bill – at 15:57
I don’t really have any sources per se. But how about this… How about, I figure out how to create a wiki page with the information and then link to that? Then we can use the thread for discussion. (Any help on learning would be appreciated.)
Would that work?
(Influentia2, any particular nation/part of the planet you had in mind?)
LMWatBullRun – at 14:33
Influentia2 – at 15:28
I was going to try to do this alphabetically. But, I do not mind going out of order…. Someone will just have to keep me straight.
I will work on those now…
FloridaGirl – at 16:14 --- That would be perfect. Once you have the Wiki pages set up (you can create one then use it as a template for the others), I’ll also link to them from the Forum Index.
crfullmoon 16:18
I went ahead and googled and found a Health News link and found some information about HHS Leavitt and a meeting in May 2006 so far. If you have some links on Lakota Sioux or Cherokee that would interest me too. Reading the beginning of this thread made me wonder how much information the American Indian has regarding pandemic flu and/or prepping. Just curious.
Thank you
Bronco Bill – at 17:37
You can use them as a template? I have finished the Main Cultural Considerations page if you want to link that page.
At the bottom, I started a list for the different cultures. AMISH is started, but not finished. Looking up info for Infuentia2 and LMWatBullRun.
Influentia2 – at 18:10
Well, I had started a few weeks ago and did research on a number of cultures, but I did not have specifically Lakota Sioux or Cherokee, although Cherokee was on my to do list. I have started doing some research, but it generally takes a few hours to put it together. Promise though… I will work on it tonight (tomorrow also, if necessary)
LMWatBullRun – at 14:33
I have already started working on your culture: Highland Scots-Irish
You should Note: I did my culture also. I was quite shocked about some of what I found. Being an American, takes you away from cultural influences (Thank Goodness)… Even though you may have very few or no generations born in America (or other country) The differences are great. Ever see “My Big, Fat, Greek Wedding”?
Florida Girl
Appreciate whatever you can provide. A link will do if space is an issue. I am going to do some research myself after I finish my Indonesian links searching out news there.
Thanks
http://www.mnisose.org/profiles/oglala.htm
nativetimes.com article about life on Pine Ridge
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pine_Ridge_Indian_Reservation
:-/
http://www.indiancountry.com/content.cfm?id=1096413661 September 15, 2006 “Preparing for the real terror; Flu pandemic remains a threat “ …”The outbreak revived world concern and vindicated the U.S. government’s decision to allot $250 million for state, tribal and local preparedness.
It’s to the credit of the U.S. Health and Human Services Department that it has included tribal officials in its training and to the credit of those tribes that have stepped up. American Indians and Alaska Natives are on the front line. Subsistence hunters in Alaska are providing first warning of the appearance of avian flu in the migratory flyways from Asia. They have helped provide 13,000 carcasses from 26 species for testing by the Interior and Agriculture departments, in a program now being expanded to include the lower 48 states. (So far none have shown the highly pathogenic form of H5N1, although a mild strain has turned up in Michigan swans and Maryland and Pennsylvania mallards.)
Emergency planning officers in tribes from the St. Regis Mohawk in upstate New York to the Lakota nations in the northern Plains to the Navajo in the Southwest have been preparing to cope with an outbreak. They face the added factor of rural isolation and realize they might have to rely on their own resources for much of the response. Other tribes in more densely populated regions are coordinating planning closely with state and local governments.
Casino-owning tribes could find themselves at the nodes of an epidemic, especially those with heavy international traffic. They could also bear the economic brunt of a quarantine.
By leading in the preparedness planning, tribal governments are not only tending to their own safety and the safety of their members, but vindicating their claims to sovereignty and self-determination as well. Performance is the best proof for self-government. In the American system of federalism, the governments that show they can do the job tend to gain a more respectful hearing for their claims to authority. This isn’t invariably true, of course, but states’ rights began to gain more favor in federal courts in the 1970s when state governments could show their programs were more innovative and effective than their federal counterparts. The more tribes lead in providing services like pandemic preparedness, the more respect they will command.
The St. Regis Mohawk Tribe, for instance, deserves commendation for its efforts to share its expertise with other tribes. Although its first attempt to host a conference on pandemic planning did not attract sufficient interest, it intends to try again in October or November when other tribes should be more focused on the threat.
Indian country, more than most other peoples of the world, should be sensitive to the impact of disease”…
crfullmoon 19:55
Thanks for the links.
FloridaGirl – at 18:55 --- Your main Cultural Considerations page is now linked in the Forum Index here
LMWatBullRun,
Because the highland scot-irish culture is part of the Appalachian heritage. I combined them under the broader title, or I would end up duplicating information.
Link to Appalachian Heritage page.
http://tinyurl.com/y3g5ad
Link to the Main Culture Page
http://tinyurl.com/tu4tk
I will be back with my observations after I think about it for a while.
Bronco Bill – at 22:16
Thank you kind Sir…
Y’welcome. Let me know when you add more “culture” to the page :-). wturner3 at gmail dot com. I’ll add those as I did with the Amish link…
Bronco Bill – at 22:27
Thank you much… I have a request though. Could you change the link for “Cultural COnsideration and their impact on individuals and Communities” at the top of that page to just take you directly to the link instead of further down the page. I will add to the top of the “Culture Main Page” Something like: “Specific culture Links at Bottom”
That way, the Culture page will be read first.
OR Change the wording on the first (top) link to…. “Overcoming barriers; Understanding Culture”
OR Change the wording on the first (top) link to…. “Considering Culture for Interventions”
Someone help me here…. My brain is dead!
My Thoughts on…
Appalachian Heritage
Communicating the risks:
“Because of past experiences with large mining and timber companies, many dislike authority figures and institutions that attempt to control behavior. It may be helpful to “sit a spell” and “chat” before getting down to the business of collecting health information. To establish trust, it is necessary to demonstrate an interest in the client’s family and other personal matters, drop hints instead of giving orders, and solicit clients’ opinions and advice.”
FloridaGirl – at 23:21 --- Let me see what I can do.
FloridaGirl – at 23:21 --- Slight change in the links set-up on the Forum Index: I’ve left the name to reflect what your title here says. Click on the title towards the top of the page under “Personal Prepping” (that may change if/when I find a better heading to put it under); that will take you down the Forum Index page to the link to this thread, a Forum thread.
I’ve also included a link immediately below that link that will take you to the Wiki Page you created.
Also, I’ve added your Wiki page to the Wiki Index under “C” for Cultural. Hope this helps…let me know…
Now let’s do it and include the proper links!!
These are links to the Forum pages:
And these are links to the Wiki pages:
Should have a language barrier, dealing with visually/hearing impaired link……
Grace RN --- No threads or Wiki pages available to link to… :-(
Bronco Bill – at 16:04
Thank You! You are so very helpful!
Grace RN – at 16:11
That is a great Idea. Maybe we should build an entry page called
“Barriers” i.e.
Do you want to start pages on Language barriers, visual/hearing impaired; Maybe a special needs page?
FloridaGirl – at 19:12 --- It’s what I do. ;-)
FloridaGirl – at 19:12 --- Glad to help. It’s what I do. ;-)
Influentia2
I haven’t forgotten you… I have found LOTS of great info on Cherokee’s (Problem is… most of what I am finding are great stories, and historical culture. (And Of course I am reading them… ). That goes into the historical view…. But there isn’t any consistency in some of the certain areas I am trying to provide information on. I am researching the Journals now…
I have to take a short break until this weekend… School and scholarship stuff….
I will try to find you a story I read that was used to teach children about character.
I find there is truth in these stories….
Cherokee Wisdom\\
One evening an old Cherokee told his grandson about a battle that goes on inside people. “My son, the battle is between two wolves,” the old Cherokee said. “One wolf is evil. It is anger, envy, sorrow, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride, superiority, and ego. The other wolf is good. It is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, benevolence, empathy, generosity, truth, compassion, and faith.” “This is a battle that rages inside of each of us… this battle of the wolves….”
The grandson thought about it for a minute and then asked his grandfather, “Which wolf wins?”
The old Cherokee simply replied, “The one you feed.”